Roths

[Mocchaccino]

This is nonsense. It's no proof whatsoever that just because a nursery has a good reputation that they are beyond question.
Anything could have happened in the breeding line. Especially if any of the the progenitors of the cross came from Asia!
A non argument.

All ancestral paphs were orignated all over the tropical Asia.

 

[Stone]

someone who has never even flowered a roth or seen one in flower

True I have not flowered one yet but you are making the same mistake you accuse me of by supposing I have never seen one.
Actually I have seen about 7 or 8 different clones. Not that that should make any difference.

shouldn't be making statements like "there's no way that's a roth". You made a very direct statement.

Correct. Therefore I retract my statement and replace it with. ''That does not look like a pure roth to me''

 

[Stone]

All ancestral paphs were orignated all over the tropical Asia.

Ha Ha Very funny. I mean out of Asian Nurseries...