Gregor
Member
Googling on eBay I have found this seller that bid a declared Paphiopedilum rothschildianum. Could you give me some opinion about that?
Many thanks
Many thanks
True Paphiopedilum rothschildianum - ebay seller
- Thread starter Gregor
- Start date
Help Support Slippertalk Orchid Forum:
NYEric
Well-Known Member
Hi. What do you mean a "declared" roth? You can copy and save the link in your post so we can see what you are talking about.
AdamD
Catasetinae Crazed
I got my roth as a first bloom seedling on eBay a few years back from a reputeable dealer. It is now a multi growth plant that has rebloomed. Just be conscious of the seller's reviews. And beware cold shipping conditions this late in the year
Gregor
Member
Sorry I have forgotten to post the link
http://www.ebay.it/itm/161144376364?ssPageName=STRK:MEBIDX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1426.l2649
ehanes7612
Well-Known Member
that could be a roth..wont really know until it blooms
E
eds
Guest
Never dealt with the seller but you might want to read some other people's opinions, http://www.ukorchidforum.com/viewtopic.php?f=6&t=5822
NYEric
Well-Known Member
The plant in the photo looks OK, but as Ed says, you wnt know until it blooms. The feedback level is pretty high so that accounts for something.
John M
Orchid Addict
Do not deal with this seller! He's a rip off artist! He has stolen my photos and used them to sell his plants, lying to his customers as he represents my plants as the ones he's going to send to the auction winners. He totally ignored my e-mails and continued to use my photos. He also has ignored and not paid the invoice I sent to him. This guy is only out to make a buck and he does not care about honesty! If you send him money for a plant, God only knows what he'll send to you, if he sends anything!
gotsomerice
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Mar 18, 2008
- Messages
- 185
- Reaction score
- 0
Those leaves look more like roth hybrid to me. Chiu Hua Dancer maybe? Roth's leaves are more narrow, erect and the tips are pointing up? What do you guys think?
SlipperFan
Addicted
I think I'd listen to John.
If you have any doubt about what John says about the seller check out the picture on this link
https://www.orchidweb.com/products/paph-rothschildianum~3127.html
https://www.orchidweb.com/products/paph-rothschildianum~3127.html
SlipperFan
Addicted
I wonder what Dr. Rob thinks of that photo...
I think the other flower picture is his also.
SlipperFan
Addicted
Proves your point. And John's.
It's always possible that he has permission to use the pictures but based on John's comment it's doubtful.
SlipperFan
Addicted
I'll point out the link to Rob.
Gregor stay away from this,him stolen photo ,also if this roth is no bad but all plant that him sell are in very bad condition,(stay alert ,it could be only an illusion)him change name sometime on ebay but the plant are the same,recognizably too. I bought from him,I don't remember exactly maybe a years ago a Delrosi ,I was impressed more from flower photo than plant itself,I have done the mistakes of beginner.
and I remember that at the end of bid when the seller convert the price pound in euro I paid a lot more than I was thought before ,I find from the leave also trace of cochineal ,the plant was dehydrate too and only one growth is good enough, at the end of story I paid the plant 40euro and more,a very expensive price for a bad and tiny plant , now I put him on my blacklist .
on ukorchidforum have spoken negatively about this person too but unfortunately I have arrived late
stai all'occhio ,ciao gregorio,anna
and I remember that at the end of bid when the seller convert the price pound in euro I paid a lot more than I was thought before ,I find from the leave also trace of cochineal ,the plant was dehydrate too and only one growth is good enough, at the end of story I paid the plant 40euro and more,a very expensive price for a bad and tiny plant , now I put him on my blacklist .
on ukorchidforum have spoken negatively about this person too but unfortunately I have arrived late
stai all'occhio ,ciao gregorio,anna
D
Dido
Guest
he changes often names, he only sale what is rare and searched for.
I think he often read this forum, then a while after a pic is published here, he starts to offer them.
He sold 3 times, the same in bud plant, and the people bought it get one without bud.
I think he buys plants which are cheap or in normal store and most turn out to be complex.
He looks in which direction it can go and then he post it.
I asked him a few times where he got his plants for, and how can he prove it. He always replyed thathe has the agreement of using this pics.
Then I contacted a few of the members here and none of them have given him the agreement. But after to many negative feedback he starts with a new name. often the plant is cut in fresh pices and then has not many change to survive. the same for other kinds of orchids.
I have 2 friends who was chased up, I was always scared to buy, as his offers was to good to be true.
I think at least one member out here told me when we discussed this vendor beofre in a dfferent thread, that she think he is no what I think from this person, actual there is at least 3 names in eBay he sell.
We have a similar person in germany.
And another one who still is doing this he sell nearly all, even if the plant is not legal....
I think he often read this forum, then a while after a pic is published here, he starts to offer them.
He sold 3 times, the same in bud plant, and the people bought it get one without bud.
I think he buys plants which are cheap or in normal store and most turn out to be complex.
He looks in which direction it can go and then he post it.
I asked him a few times where he got his plants for, and how can he prove it. He always replyed thathe has the agreement of using this pics.
Then I contacted a few of the members here and none of them have given him the agreement. But after to many negative feedback he starts with a new name. often the plant is cut in fresh pices and then has not many change to survive. the same for other kinds of orchids.
I have 2 friends who was chased up, I was always scared to buy, as his offers was to good to be true.
I think at least one member out here told me when we discussed this vendor beofre in a dfferent thread, that she think he is no what I think from this person, actual there is at least 3 names in eBay he sell.
We have a similar person in germany.
And another one who still is doing this he sell nearly all, even if the plant is not legal....
ehanes7612
Well-Known Member
looks exactly like a geen valley x dou fang i once bloomed..roths can vary in growth habits and i dont see any incentive in lying about it being a roth over a chia hua dancer as they are equally in demand
ehanes7612
Well-Known Member
so,how does one explain all the great reviews (hundreds) he has?
Similar threads
